Are They Lying to Us About SEO? | ITM News and Articles

Are They Lying to Us About SEO?

Search engine optimization (SEO) has long been marketed as the golden ticket to online success—the magic formula that guarantees rankings, traffic, and business growth. But if you've ever tried to keep up with Google’s ever-changing algorithms, you’ve probably realized that much of what’s preached about SEO is either outdated, misleading, or flat-out wrong.

From the belief that stuffing pages with keywords will send rankings soaring to the obsession with backlinks as the ultimate authority signal, SEO has been wrapped in myths that refuse to die. Meanwhile, search engines have evolved, prioritizing user experience, content quality, and intent-driven searches over the tricks and tactics that once worked.

So, have we been fed a bunch of SEO nonsense? It’s time to set the record straight. Below, we break down some of the biggest SEO myths still floating around and what the reality looks like in today’s search landscape.

search engine optimization

Myth #1: SEO is All About Keywords

What They Tell You:

If you want to rank on Google, just stuff your website with keywords—the more, the better. Toss in exact-match phrases wherever possible, load up your meta tags, and boom! Your site shoots to the top of search results.

The Reality: SEO Is About User Intent, Not Just Keywords

There was a time when SEO was as simple as cramming a page with keywords and calling it a day. In the early days of search engines, Google’s ranking algorithm was heavily reliant on keyword frequency. If a page mentioned “best running shoes” fifty times, Google assumed it was highly relevant and rewarded it with a top spot.

But those days are long gone.

Google has evolved beyond basic keyword matching and now prioritizes user intent and content quality over repetitive phrasing. The search engine doesn’t just look for exact words—it analyzes the context behind a search query. It wants to understand what the user actually needs, not just whether a page contains a specific phrase.

Let’s say someone searches for “best running shoes for knee pain.” A keyword-stuffed page might say:

"Looking for the best running shoes? Our best running shoes are the best for anyone looking for the best running shoes. Buy our best running shoes today!"
Google sees right through this nonsense. It doesn’t answer the user’s question, and it certainly doesn’t provide any real value. Instead, Google now prioritizes well-written, informative content that directly addresses the query. A page that includes:

  • A breakdown of the best running shoes for knee pain
  • A comparison of cushioning and support levels
  • Insights from podiatrists or running experts
  • Real customer reviews on comfort and durability

…is far more likely to rank, even if it doesn’t use the exact phrase “best running shoes for knee pain” fifty times.

The Death of Keyword Stuffing (and What Works Instead)

Google’s algorithm updates—like BERT and RankBrain—focus on natural language processing. They evaluate content the way a human would, identifying relevance, readability, and intent instead of just scanning for keywords.

This means keyword stuffing is not only ineffective—it actively hurts your rankings. Pages overloaded with repetitive phrases come across as spammy, low-value content, causing Google to push them down in search results.

Instead of obsessing over exact keyword placement, the real focus should be on:

  • Understanding search intent – What problem is the user trying to solve?
  • Using natural language – Write as if you're speaking to a real person, not a search engine.
  • Providing comprehensive answers – Cover the topic in depth so the user doesn’t need to search elsewhere.
  • Including related terms and synonyms – Google understands variations (e.g., “top sneakers for knee pain” still aligns with “best running shoes for knee support”).

The Real Solution

Google’s algorithm is smarter than ever, and gaming the system with keyword tricks won’t work. SEO success comes from content that is genuinely useful, well-structured, and aligned with what users are looking for.

The best approach? Stop writing for algorithms—start writing for people.

Myth #2: Backlinks Are the Ultimate Ranking Factor

What They Tell You:

If you want to rank high on Google, get as many backlinks as possible—it doesn’t matter where they come from or how they’re built. The more links pointing to your site, the better your rankings will be.

The Reality: Backlinks Matter, But They Aren’t Everything

For years, backlinks were seen as the gold standard of SEO. The logic was simple: If a website has thousands of links pointing to it, Google must see it as important, right?

Not exactly.

Google does use backlinks as a ranking signal, but it has become far more selective about which links actually matter. A high number of low-quality, spammy, or irrelevant backlinks won’t boost your rankings—they’ll do the opposite. Google’s Penguin algorithm update cracked down on manipulative link-building tactics, penalizing sites that relied on link farms, paid backlinks, and artificial strategies to game the system.

Today, the focus is on quality over quantity. A handful of backlinks from relevant, high-authority sites in your industry will carry far more weight than hundreds of links from random blogs, directories, or forum spam.

Why Bad Backlinks Can Hurt Your Rankings

Back in the day, black-hat SEO tactics revolved around buying backlinks in bulk. Website owners would flood their domains with links from irrelevant blogs, shady PBNs (private blog networks), and comment sections filled with garbage anchor text.

But Google wised up. Now, toxic backlinks can actually trigger manual penalties or algorithmic demotions. If your site is linked to from questionable sources, Google may assume you're trying to manipulate rankings and push you further down in search results.

Here’s what that looks like in real life:

  • Backlinks from irrelevant sites: If you own a local plumbing business, a backlink from a casino or payday loan website isn’t just useless—it looks unnatural.
  • Links from low-quality directories: Once upon a time, directory submissions were a go-to SEO trick. Now, most low-tier directories do nothing for SEO and may even be flagged as spam.
  • Comment spam links: “Great article! Check out my website for the best weight loss pills!”—this kind of link-building is not just ineffective, it’s outright damaging.
  • PBN links: Private blog networks (PBNs) are a network of sites built solely to link to each other. Google actively hunts these down, and if your site is caught benefiting from them, you’ll see rankings plummet.

What Actually Works: Earning High-Quality Backlinks

Instead of chasing large numbers of backlinks, the real focus should be on earning valuable, authoritative links that boost credibility and relevance.

  • Create Link-Worthy Content – People link to content that is unique, valuable, and insightful. Publish research, case studies, guides, or industry reports that others in your niche will want to reference.
  • Build Relationships, Not Just Links – Engage with your industry. Guest post on reputable sites, contribute expert quotes to articles, and collaborate with influencers.
  • Get Featured in High-Authority Publications – Sites like Forbes, HubSpot, and industry-specific news outlets carry massive SEO weight. Earning a backlink from a trusted source is worth more than 500 spammy links.
  • Leverage Digital PR & Outreach – Instead of begging for backlinks, build genuine connections with journalists, bloggers, and businesses in your industry. If you create something valuable, they’ll naturally link to it.

The Real Solution

Backlinks still matter, but they’re not a shortcut to instant rankings. A strong SEO strategy is about earning trust and authority naturally, not chasing artificial link-building schemes.

Focus on content quality, industry relevance, and organic growth, and your rankings will reflect it.

seo strategy

Myth #3: SEO Guarantees Traffic

What They Tell You:

Rank high on Google, and your website will be flooded with traffic. SEO is a magic formula—just crack the code, and visitors will come rolling in.

The Reality: Ranking High Doesn't Guarantee Clicks

Many businesses assume that ranking on the first page of Google means automatic success. After all, if your website appears at the top of search results, people will click on it, right?

Not necessarily.

SEO can get you visibility, but it doesn’t guarantee engagement. Even if you rank first for a keyword, there’s no guarantee people will click through—or that they’ll stay on your site if they do.
Google’s Search Engine Results Page (SERP) is more competitive than ever. Between paid ads, featured snippets, local map packs, and image carousels, organic rankings are no longer the only game in town. In many cases, Google answers the user’s question directly on the results page, meaning they don’t even need to click a link.

For example, search for "What is the capital of France?" and Google will instantly display the answer: Paris. If your website relies on traffic for these types of informational queries, you might rank—but you might not get any visitors.

Why Ranking Doesn’t Always Lead to Traffic

Even if your page ranks well, several factors influence whether users actually click your link:

  • Boring or Unclear Titles: If your title doesn’t grab attention, people will scroll past it.
  • Weak Meta Descriptions: A vague or unhelpful description won’t encourage clicks.
  • Better Competitor Listings: If another result looks more relevant, more compelling, or more visually engaging, users will choose it instead.
  • Search Intent Mismatch: If your content doesn’t directly align with what users are looking for, they won’t click—or worse, they’ll bounce immediately.

How to Turn Rankings into Real Traffic

If SEO alone doesn’t guarantee visitors, what does? Optimizing for clicks, engagement, and retention.

  • Write Click-Worthy Titles – Your page title is the first thing users see. Make it compelling, specific, and curiosity-inducing without being clickbait. A title like "10 Surprising SEO Myths Holding Your Business Back" is more enticing than "SEO Myths."
  • Optimize Meta Descriptions – This is your chance to sell the click. Instead of stuffing in keywords, craft a short, engaging summary that tells users why they should visit your page.
  • Satisfy Search Intent – If someone searches "best digital marketing strategies for 2024", they want updated, expert-backed insights—not a generic, outdated article. Align your content with what the user expects.
  • Improve User Experience (UX) – If your site loads slowly, looks unprofessional, or is difficult to navigate, visitors will leave immediately—hurting your rankings over time. A fast, mobile-friendly, visually appealing site keeps users engaged.
  • Use Internal Links to Keep Visitors Engaged – Once you have someone on your site, give them more reasons to stay. Link to related articles, resources, or products to reduce bounce rates and increase session duration.

The Real Solution

SEO isn’t just about getting to the top—it’s about earning the click and keeping users engaged once they land on your page. A high ranking doesn’t mean much if people aren’t clicking or staying.

Focus on creating compelling, user-focused content that’s worth engaging with, and traffic will follow.

Myth #4: Longer Content Always Ranks Better

What They Tell You:

The longer the article, the higher it ranks. If you want to dominate Google, write 2,500+ word blog posts every time—regardless of whether the topic actually needs that much content.

The Reality: Quality Over Quantity, Every Time

There’s a common belief that Google favors long-form content. While in-depth articles often rank well, length alone is not the deciding factor. If that were true, every 5,000-word article would outrank every 1,000-word piece, and that’s simply not the case.

Google’s priority is answering user queries as efficiently as possible. Sometimes that requires an in-depth guide; other times, a short, concise answer is all that’s needed. A 500-word article that directly addresses a question will outrank a 2,500-word essay full of fluff and repetition.

Why More Words Don’t Always Mean Better Rankings

Several factors influence whether longer content is actually beneficial:

  • Search intent matters more than word count. A page answering “What’s the time in New York?” doesn’t need 2,000 words—it just needs to display the correct time.
  • User engagement signals influence rankings. If visitors land on a lengthy post but leave after a few seconds, Google sees that as a sign the content didn’t satisfy their search intent.
  • Long content that lacks structure is overwhelming. Readers don’t want to scroll endlessly through irrelevant backstory and filler text. If they can’t quickly find what they need, they’ll bounce.

How to Write Content That Actually Ranks

Instead of focusing on word count for the sake of SEO, the real goal should be providing the most complete and engaging answer to a user’s question.

  • Match content length to user intent. Some topics need depth; others don’t. A quick, direct answer can often outperform a bloated article.
  • Make content skimmable. Use headings, bullet points, and concise paragraphs so readers can easily find the information they need.
  • Prioritize engagement over length. Articles with high time on page, low bounce rates, and strong internal linking send better ranking signals than long but poorly structured content.
  • Update and refine existing content. A well-maintained, high-quality 1,000-word article will perform better than a stagnant 3,000-word post that hasn’t been updated in years.

The Real Solution

SEO isn’t about hitting a magic word count—it’s about providing the best answer in the most effective way. Whether that takes 500 or 2,500 words depends entirely on the topic and what users expect.
A long, poorly written article won’t rank just because of its length. But well-structured, value-packed content that keeps readers engaged will always perform well—regardless of how many words it takes.

seo

Myth #5: SEO is a One-and-Done Task

What They Tell You:

Once you optimize your website for SEO, you’re set for life. Do it right the first time, and there’s no need to make ongoing changes.

The Reality: SEO is an Ongoing Process

Many businesses treat SEO like a checkbox on a to-do list—something to set up once and forget about. The truth is, SEO is never truly “finished”. Search engines constantly evolve, competition increases, and user behavior shifts over time. What works today may be irrelevant or ineffective in six months.

Think of SEO like fitness. You can’t hit the gym for a month, get in shape, and then stop exercising forever while expecting to stay fit. Just like staying healthy requires consistent effort, maintaining strong search rankings requires ongoing optimization, updates, and strategic adjustments.

Why SEO Can’t Be a One-Time Effort

Several factors make continuous SEO work necessary:

  • Google’s algorithms change constantly. Major updates like Panda, Penguin, and Core Web Vitals have reshaped SEO rules, penalizing outdated tactics and rewarding new ranking factors.
  • Competitors don’t stop optimizing. Even if you hold the top position today, other businesses are constantly improving their SEO to outrank you.
  • User behavior evolves. Search trends shift, new keywords emerge, and what people want from search results changes over time.
  • Content gets outdated. Even the best-performing content loses relevance if it isn’t updated regularly. A guide written in 2021 may no longer reflect the latest best practices in 2024.

How to Keep SEO Working for You

Since SEO isn’t a one-and-done task, the best strategy is to make it part of ongoing business operations.

  • Update and refresh content regularly. Google favors fresh, relevant, and up-to-date pages. Revisiting older content and adding new insights, updated statistics, and recent developments keeps your rankings strong.
  • Monitor rankings and analytics. SEO tools like Google Search Console, Ahrefs, and SEMrush help track keyword performance, traffic patterns, and potential technical issues before they become major problems.
  • Adapt to Google’s algorithm updates. When Google rolls out new ranking factors, adjusting content, site speed, or technical SEO ensures you don’t lose visibility.
  • Continuously build authority. SEO success isn’t just about one-time link-building or keyword optimization—it’s about maintaining credibility and trust in your industry through ongoing efforts.

The Real Solution

SEO is a long-term game, not a one-time project. Staying ahead in search rankings requires constant monitoring, regular content updates, and adapting to changes in search behavior and algorithms.
The businesses that prioritize ongoing SEO efforts—rather than treating it as a set-it-and-forget-it task—are the ones that continue to grow, stay competitive, and maintain strong visibility in search results.

Myth #6: Google Wants to Help You Rank

What They Tell You:

Google is on your side. If you follow best practices, the search engine will reward your website with higher rankings and more visibility.

The Reality: Google’s Priority is Google—Not You

Many businesses assume that Google’s goal is to help websites succeed—but in reality, Google’s main focus is serving users and maximizing its own revenue.

While Google does provide SEO guidelines and tools like Search Console to help webmasters improve their sites, these aren’t designed to help you rank higher out of goodwill. They exist to ensure that Google delivers the best experience for its users—which doesn’t always align with what’s best for businesses.

Google’s algorithms frequently change, and updates often prioritize keeping users on Google itself rather than sending them to external websites. Features like featured snippets, knowledge panels, and instant answers mean that many users find what they need without ever clicking a link. This reduces organic traffic to websites, making businesses even more dependent on Google Ads and paid promotion.

Why You Shouldn’t Rely on Google Alone

Google’s algorithm changes can dramatically impact rankings overnight. Many websites that once thrived on organic search traffic have seen their visibility plummet due to core updates, increased competition, or changes in how search results are displayed.

  • Algorithm updates can wipe out rankings. Even if a site follows best practices, it’s still vulnerable to major shifts in ranking criteria.
  • Google favors its own products. Search results often prioritize Google Ads, Google Maps, Google Shopping, and featured snippets, reducing clicks on organic listings.
  • Zero-click searches are increasing. More users find answers directly on Google, leading to fewer visits to websites.
  • Organic traffic isn’t guaranteed. Even well-optimized sites can lose traffic as Google changes how it ranks and presents information.

How to Build a More Sustainable Digital Marketing Strategy

Since Google’s ranking system is unpredictable, relying solely on organic search traffic is a risky business move. The best approach is to diversify and develop multiple channels for reaching your audience.

  • Build an email list. Email marketing provides direct access to your audience, reducing dependence on Google for traffic.
  • Invest in brand awareness. A strong brand presence ensures people search for you directly, rather than relying on Google to find you.
  • Use multiple traffic sources. Leverage social media, paid advertising, partnerships, and content marketing to reach your audience across different platforms.
  • Develop community engagement. Encourage repeat visitors through newsletters, memberships, and direct user engagement instead of relying on unpredictable search traffic.

The Real Solution

Google isn’t a business partner—it’s a for-profit company that serves its own interests first. While SEO is important, businesses should never rely on Google alone for traffic and visibility.
A smarter strategy involves building direct relationships with your audience, creating strong brand recognition, and using multiple channels to drive consistent engagement. The websites that adapt and diversify are the ones that remain resilient—no matter what Google does next.

ITM – Website Design and Search Engine Company

For years, SEO has been surrounded by half-truths, outdated tactics, and exaggerated promises. Businesses are told that ranking is just about keywords, backlinks, and length, or that once you hit page one, traffic is guaranteed. The reality? SEO is far more complex, and success requires a strategy that adapts to evolving search trends, user behavior, and Google’s ever-changing algorithms.

Instead of chasing quick fixes and outdated ranking tricks, businesses should focus on creating valuable content, building trust, and diversifying traffic sources. Search engine optimization still matters, but it’s just one part of a larger digital marketing strategy that includes content marketing, brand authority, and direct audience engagement.

Get in touch with us to create an SEO strategy that’s built to last.

Comments are closed for this post, but if you have spotted an error or have additional info that you think should be in this post, feel free to contact us.

Get the latest updates in your email box automatically.

 

Why Pay More?

Search

Tags

Browse all tags